Dopamine (DA) signaling is critically important in striatal function, and this metabolically demanding process is fueled largely by glucose. However, DA and glucose are typically studied independently and, as such, the precise relationship between DA release and glucose availability remains unclear. Fast-scan cyclic voltammetry (FSCV) is commonly coupled with carbon-fiber microelectrodes to study DA transients. These microelectrodes can be modified with glucose oxidase (GOx) to generate microbiosensors capable of simultaneously quantifying real-time and physiologically relevant fluctuations of glucose, a nonelectrochemically active substrate, and DA, which is readily oxidized and reduced at the electrode surface. A chitosan hydrogel can be electrodeposited to entrap the oxidase enzyme on the sensor surface for stable, sensitive, and selective codetection of glucose and DA using FSCV. This strategy can also be used to entrap lactate oxidase on the carbon-fiber surface for codetection of lactate and DA. However, these custom probes are individually fabricated by hand, and performance is variable. This study characterizes the physical nature of the hydrogel and its effects on the acquired electrochemical data in the detection of glucose (2.6 mM) and DA (1 μM). The results demonstrate that the electrodeposition of the hydrogel membrane is improved using a linear potential sweep rather than a direct step to the target potential. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy data relate information on the physical nature of the electrode/solution interface to the electrochemical performance of bare and enzyme-modified carbon-fiber microelectrodes. The electrodeposition waveform and scan rate were characterized for optimal membrane formation and performance. Finally, codetection of both DA/glucose and DA/lactate was demonstrated in intact rat striatum using probes fabricated according to the optimized protocol. Overall, this work improves the reliable fabrication of carbon-fiber microbiosensors for codetection of DA and important energetic substrates that are locally delivered to the recording site to meet metabolic demand.