2024 journal article
Researchers must address regulatory regimes to scale up adoption of urine diversion systems in the U.S.
Environmental Research: Infrastructure and Sustainability.
open access via doi.org (publisher)
UN Sustainable Development Goal Categories
6. Clean Water and Sanitation
(Web of Science)
Source: ORCID
Added: July 8, 2024
Abstract Urine diversion (UD) is a system-of-systems that involves source separation of waste to maximize recovery of valuable nutrients, including phosphorus. Recent research shows how UD systems offer valuable ecological benefits and can aid in water conservation efforts, and public perception studies suggest that UD systems are generally viewed positively by end-users and the general public. Nevertheless, adoption and implementation of this promising sustainability solution remains limited in many countries, including the United States (U.S.). In this perspective, we argue that in order to scale up adoption in the U.S., UD researchers and innovators must do more to address regulatory barriers. We draw on insights from political science research on “regulatory regimes” to introduce the array of regulations that apply to UD systems, with a focus on commercial and institutional buildings. We examine regulatory regimes all along the UD system-of-systems, beginning at the point of collection and ending at the point of beneficial reuse. We then propose next steps to address current regulatory challenges that impact adoption, with an emphasis on the importance of stakeholder coordination. Throughout, we argue that law and regulation plays a critical role in shaping adoption of UD technologies because: 1) different regulatory regimes will be important at different points in the system-of-systems, 2) there may be multiple regulatory regimes that apply to a single subsystem, and 3) it is important to consider that legal and regulatory definitions of a technology may not match scientific understanding.